Are HBO’s dragons flame throwers or bomb throwers.

HBO

ThereĀ  were more problems with ‘Game of Thrones’ season 8, episode 5, “The Bells,” than just the lack of a reasonable motivation for Daenerys Targaryen to do what she did to Kings Landing. The weapon she used on the city to become Queen of the ashes in the penultimate installment of the series is inconsistent with any kind of physics, be it real or whatever passes for laws of the natural world in Westeros.

You better believe spoilers follow.

Let’s go back in time just a little bit to the Battle of Winterfell in episode 3, “The Long Night.” Just before Arya Stark goes full ninja on the Night King, we see Jon Snow hunkering down behind walls and even smallish piles of rubble to keep from getting broiled by the blue flames of the zombie-fied version of Viserion the dragon.

Just keep those images in your mind. And maybe also recall the Night King getting blasted by a stream of orange flame from Drogon without taking any damage or even being knocked back.

Now try to square that with the dragon breath from “The Bells” that blows apart countless thick stone castle and city walls.

Where exactly is the hurricane wind-level force that would be required to do this much damage coming from? And why is this the first time any dragons in the show have turned on this ability? We’re apparently supposed to believe that the dragons are capable of controlling the velocity of their breath anywhere from a gentle breeze that roasts the Tarlys where they stand to some serious category 5 flamethrowing.

But the destruction on display at King’s Landing actually seems like the writers simply decided that a stream of fire should work the same as a bomb or projectile weapon. This forgets, of course, that the latter draw their destructive power from force owed to either an engineered explosion or a significant mass, like a cannon ball. Fiery breath, on the other hand, is just heat and a little wind. The force required for dragons to blow that hard would require some rather insane lungs and diaphragm, especially while flying.

But, okay, it’s silly to split hairs about the biology of one of the longest-running fantasy trope creatures. Why, then, did Drogon not go full gale-force fire on the Night King at the Battle of Winterfell, leaving him standing in a crater of destruction consistent with the damage the same dragon effortlessly inflicted on the Red Keep two episodes later?

One diligent Redditor offered a potential explanation for the clear confusion of simple fire with bombs:

“Assuming that dragon fire is hot enough, when you spill hot liquid metal on stone, and particularly concrete and porous stone, the water trapped within the stone’s matrix can flash over immediately to steam and cause it to explode, spalling the stone and sending shrapnel everywhere. You can do this with a welding/brazing torch or even a big enough fresnel lens, if you’re the kind of nerd that builds a fresnel lens.”

It’s a feasible notion, but in “The Bells” it’s clear from the moment Drogon blasts out the gate to King’s Landing from the inside that we’re meant to believe it’s the unidirectional force of the dragon breath itself that is the source of the blast.

Maybe it’s not physics that’s different in Westeros, but logic. In the Westeros of HBO’s creation, it’s logical for a noble leader who freed slaves to kill thousands of children just because she’s been feeling lonely lately, so perhaps it’s also logical that fire and bombs are the same thing just because it looks cooler that way.

” readability=”77.579391891892″>
< div _ ngcontent-c14 =" " innerhtml ="

(******* )

Are HBO’s dragons flame throwers or bomb throwers.

HBO

(************ )There were more issues with ‘ Video Game of Thrones’ season 8, episode 5, “The Bells,” than simply the absence of an affordable inspiration for Daenerys Targaryen to do what she did to Kings Landing. The weapon she utilized on the city to end up being Queen of the ashes in the penultimate installation of the series is irregular with any sort of physics, be it genuine or whatever passes for laws of the natural world in Westeros.

You much better think spoilers follow.

Let’s return in time simply a bit to the Fight of Winterfell in episode 3, “The Long Night.” Prior To Arya Stark goes complete ninja on the Night King, we see Jon Snow hunching down behind walls and even small stacks of debris to avoid getting broiled by the blue flames of the zombie-fied variation of Viserion the dragon.

(****************** )

(************ )Simply keep those images in your mind. And perhaps likewise remember the Night King getting blasted by a stream of orange flame from Drogon without taking any damage or perhaps being knocked back.

(********* )

Now attempt to square that with the dragon breath from” The Bells” that blows apart numerous thick stone castle and city walls.

Where precisely is the typhoon wind-level force that would be needed to do this much damage originating from? And why is this the very first time any dragons in the program have switched on this capability? We’re obviously expected to think that the dragons can managing the speed of their breath anywhere from a mild breeze that roasts the Tarlys where they stand to some major classification 5 flamethrowing.

However the damage on display screen at King’s Landing in fact appears like the authors merely chose that a stream of fire need to work the like a bomb or projectile weapon. This forgets, obviously, that the latter draw their damaging power from force owed to either a crafted surge or a considerable mass, like a cannon ball. Intense breath, on the other hand, is simply heat and a little wind. The force needed for dragons to blow that tough would need some rather outrageous lungs and diaphragm, specifically while flying.

However, alright, it’s ridiculous to divide hairs about the biology of among the longest-running dream trope animals. Why, then, did Drogon not go complete gale-force fire on the Night King at the Fight of Winterfell, leaving him standing in a crater of damage constant with the damage the exact same dragon easily caused on the Red Keep 2 episodes later on?

One thorough Redditor provided a possible description for the clear confusion of basic fire with bombs:

” Presuming that dragon fire is hot enough, when you spill hot liquid metal on stone, and especially concrete and permeable stone, the water caught within the stone’s matrix can flash over right away to steam and trigger it to take off, spalling the stone and sending out shrapnel all over. You can do this with a welding/brazing torch or perhaps a huge sufficient fresnel lens, if you’re the sort of geek that constructs a fresnel lens.”

It’s a practical concept, however in “The Bells” it’s clear from the minute Drogon blasts out eviction to King’s Landing from the within that we’re indicated to think it’s the unidirectional force of the dragon breath itself that is the source of the blast.

Possibly it’s not physics that’s various in Westeros, however reasoning. In the Westeros of HBO’s production, it’s sensible for an honorable leader who released servants to eliminate countless kids even if she’s been feeling lonesome recently, so possibly it’s likewise sensible that fire and bombs are the exact same thing even if it looks cooler that method.

” readability =”77
579391891892″ >

.

Are HBO’s dragons flame throwers or bomb throwers.

HBO

.

.

There were more issues with ‘Video Game of Thrones’ season 8, episode 5, “The Bells ,” than simply the absence of an affordable inspiration for Daenerys Targaryen to do what she did to Kings Landing. The weapon she utilized on the city to end up being Queen of the ashes in the penultimate installation of the series is irregular with any sort of physics, be it genuine or whatever passes for laws of the natural world in Westeros.

You much better think spoilers follow.

Let’s return in time simply a bit to the Fight of Winterfell in episode 3, “The Long Night. ” Prior To Arya Stark goes complete ninja on the Night King, we see Jon Snow hunching down behind walls and even small stacks of debris to avoid getting broiled by the blue flames of the zombie-fied variation of Viserion the dragon.

Simply keep those images in your mind. And perhaps likewise remember the Night King getting blasted by a stream of orange flame from Drogon without taking any damage or perhaps being knocked back.

Now attempt to square that with the dragon breath from “The Bells” that blows apart numerous thick stone castle and city walls.

Where precisely is the typhoon wind-level force that would be needed to do this much damage originating from? And why is this the very first time any dragons in the program have switched on this capability? We’re obviously expected to think that the dragons can managing the speed of their breath anywhere from a mild breeze that roasts the Tarlys where they stand to some major classification 5 flamethrowing.

However the damage on display screen at King’s Landing in fact appears like the authors merely chose that a stream of fire need to work the like a bomb or projectile weapon. This forgets, obviously, that the latter draw their damaging power from force owed to either a crafted surge or a considerable mass, like a cannon ball. Intense breath, on the other hand, is simply heat and a little wind. The force needed for dragons to blow that tough would need some rather outrageous lungs and diaphragm, specifically while flying.

However, alright, it’s ridiculous to divide hairs about the biology of among the longest-running dream trope animals. Why, then, did Drogon not go complete gale-force fire on the Night King at the Fight of Winterfell, leaving him standing in a crater of damage constant with the damage the exact same dragon easily caused on the Red Keep 2 episodes later on?

One thorough Redditor provided a possible description for the clear confusion of basic fire with bombs:

“Presuming that dragon fire is hot enough, when you spill hot liquid metal on stone, and especially concrete and permeable stone, the water caught within the stone’s matrix can flash over right away to steam and trigger it to take off, spalling the stone and sending out shrapnel all over. You can do this with a welding/brazing torch or perhaps a huge sufficient fresnel lens, if you’re the sort of geek that constructs a fresnel lens.”

It’s a practical concept, however in “The Bells” it’s clear from the minute Drogon blasts out eviction to King’s Landing from the within that we’re indicated to think it’s the unidirectional force of the dragon breath itself that is the source of the blast.

Possibly it’s not physics that’s various in Westeros, however reasoning. In the Westeros of HBO’s production, it’s sensible for an honorable leader who released servants to eliminate countless kids even if she’s been feeling lonesome recently, so possibly it’s likewise sensible that fire and bombs are the exact same thing even if it looks cooler that method.