NPR’s Audie Cornish consults with ProPublica press reporter Marshall Allen about an examination detailing how health insurance companies pass the high expenses for sleep apnea breathing makers onto clients.


Great deals of individuals with a condition called sleep apnea usage breathing makers in the evening. Devices assist them sleep much better, stop the snoring that frustrates their partners and remain alert throughout the day. The makers and their devices can cost a number of hundred dollars. A brand-new ProPublica examination information the lengths health insurance companies are going to pass those expenses on to clients or prevent paying them entirely. ProPublica press reporter Marshall Allen has actually discussed this and joins us now. Invite to the program.


CORNISH: How do these makers work?

ALLEN: Well, it’s called a CPAP device, and CPAP represent constant favorable respiratory tract pressure. And essentially, a client uses a mask, and the mask jets air through the nose or through the mouth to keep the respiratory tract open throughout the night. Now, the makers likewise collect information on the client’s sleep practices. It will collect the variety of hours that the client slept. It will collect the variety of sleep disturbances sometimes that the client has. And clients presume that that information is simply being collected for their medical professionals, which it is due to the fact that the medical professionals require to understand this details so they can ensure the treatment is truly efficient.

However that information can likewise be beamed through a cordless modem to the supply business. And from there, it can be sent out typically to the insurer. And the insurer are collecting the information to identify whether the client is utilizing it enough so that the insurance provider will spend for it.

CORNISH: And this occurred to your own manager, I comprehend.

ALLEN: Yeah. So I was currently dealing with this story when among my editors, Eric Umansky, pertained to me throughout the newsroom, and he was truly alarmed. And what had actually taken place is he went to a medical professional and got a brand-new setting – a brand-new air circulation setting for his device. And the business that provides his gadget had actually sent him a modem to plug into the device. Which method they might upgrade his settings from another location, which he believed was an excellent benefit.

Well, he likewise required a brand-new mask, and they had not sent out a brand-new mask, so he called the supply business a couple days later on and stated, hello, I require my brand-new mask. And they stated, oh, well, by the method, you have not been certified with your device. You understand, last night, you just slept 2 1/2 hours. The night previously, you just slept 3 1/2 hours. Which’s when he understood that the device was really spying on him and tracking his sleep practices and sleep patterns. And the paradox is he wasn’t able to utilize the device due to the fact that he didn’t have the brand-new mask and yet they had not been sending out the brand-new mask due to the fact that they stated he wasn’t utilizing the device. So he was captured in this sort of insane Catch-22

CORNISH: At the exact same time, is this likewise unlawful? I indicate, exists any genuine legal barrier to sharing this information?

ALLEN: Never. This is legal. And when clients offer their authorization for treatment with a CPAP device and their physician recommends it, they do not always understand it, however they have actually likewise provided authorization for the insurance provider to get the details for functions of repayment.

CORNISH: Marshall Allen, what are the ramifications for this moving forward? Since sleep apnea is a quite particular condition, right? However there are insertable heart displays. There are glucose meters, right? There are Fitbits. There are a great deal of medical gadgets that are going to be sending out information about. What should we know moving forward?

ALLEN: Well, so we did take a look at other gadgets that prevail that individuals utilize, and we did discover that in a great deal of cases, you understand, with the client’s authorization, the information is being sent out to the insurer. And what clients require to be knowledgeable about is that that information is being utilized to construct a profile for each client, which profile might really wind up ranking you a greater threat. And down the roadway, it might result in a client paying greater rates for their medical insurance. And on the other side of it, there are all type of concealed manner ins which insurer are passing the expense of care on to the clients. Therefore even clients who are guaranteed, sometimes, they may be much better off not utilizing their insurance coverage than they are utilizing it.

CORNISH: ProPublica press reporter Marshall Allen – his story is on NPR’s Shots blog site. Thank you for talking with us.

ALLEN: Thank you, Audie.

Copyright © 2018 NPR. All rights scheduled. Visit our site regards to usage and consents pages at for additional details.

NPR records are produced on a rush due date by Verb8tm, Inc., an NPR professional, and produced utilizing an exclusive transcription procedure established with NPR. This text might not remain in its last type and might be upgraded or modified in the future. Precision and accessibility might differ. The reliable record of NPR’s shows is the audio record.