Brain book cover

The Idea of the Brain
Matthew Cobb
Basic Books, $32

Neuroscientists
love a good metaphor. Through the years, plumbing, telegraph wires and computers
have all been enlisted to help explain how the brain operates, neurobiologist
and historian Matthew Cobb writes in The Idea of the Brain. And like any
metaphor, those approximations all fall short.

Cobb leads a
fascinating tour of how concepts of the brain have morphed over time. His
writing is clear, thoughtful and, when called for, funny. He describes
experiments by neurosurgeon Wilder Penfield, who zapped awake patients’ brains
with electricity to provoke reactions. Zapping certain places consistently
dredged up memories, which Cobb calls “oneiric experiences.” His footnote on
the term: “Look it up. It’s exactly the
right word.” I did, and it was.

Cobb runs though the history of certain concepts used to explain how the brain works, including electricity, evolution and
neurons. Next comes a section on the present, which includes discussions of
memory, circuits and consciousness. Cobb offers tastes of the latest research, and
a heavy dose of realism. Memory studies
have made progress, but “we are still far from understanding what is
happening when we remember,” Cobb writes. Despite big efforts, “we still only
dimly understand what is going on when we see.”
Our understanding of how antidepressants work? “Virtually non-existent.”

This real talk is
refreshing, and Cobb uses it to great effect to
argue that neuroscience is stymied. “There have been many similar
moments in the past, when brain researchers became uncertain about how to
proceed,” he writes. Scientists have amassed an impressive stockpile of brain facts,
but a true understanding of how the brain works eludes us.

Don’t expect a computer metaphor to help. Like a computer, the brain’s
main job is to process information. But some experts argue that because brains are biological — they evolved within the vagaries of a body — they operate in ways that a machine doesn’t (SN: 8/23/16).

Cobb reckons
that, among other reasons, the mere existence
of such objections is a harbinger of the end of the computer metaphor.
But that doesn’t mean the comparison was a
waste. Metaphors clarify thoughts, he writes, and scientists would do well to
ponder what might replace the concept.

He ends the book with a creative exercise in
looking ahead to what the future might hold. The possibilities include the creation of conscious machines, or even having to
accept that there is no brain theory to be found. Still, “our current
ignorance should not be viewed as a sign of defeat,” Cobb writes, “but as a
challenge.”


Buy The Idea of the Brain from Amazon.com. Science News is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. Please see our FAQ for more details.