Dr. Phyllis Gardner, a Stanford Medical College professor, was used to being approached by entrepreneurial college students seeking to make a dent within the biotech world.
So when Elizabeth Holmes approached her after arriving at Stanford in 2002 with an concept to construct a patch that might scan the wearer for infections and launch antibiotics as applicable, Gardner tried to elucidate to her why that may not work. Virtually, the antibiotics Holmes needed to make use of wanted to be given at greater doses than a patch may ship, Gardner mentioned.
When she noticed that she wasn’t getting by means of to Holmes, Gardner pointed her within the course of different folks to assist, together with Gardner’s husband.
“She was going to make it work and comply with the mannequin of ‘strive it till you succeed,'” Gardner mentioned. “That’s so utterly ridiculous when it comes to healthcare.”
That method frightened Gardner even then.
“When you will have folks’s lives in danger, you do not do this,” she mentioned.
Shortly afterward, Holmes dropped out of Stanford. In 2003, at age 19, she based the blood-testing startup Theranos.
Theranos went on to lift greater than $700 million from traders, finally racking up a $9 billion valuation with its large imaginative and prescient to check for a number of situations utilizing only a small pattern of blood.
Over the next years, Gardner would hear rumors about what the corporate was as much as from individuals who had labored there. Theranos notably attracted youthful folks popping out of Stanford.
Gardner got here again into the Theranos story when Richard Fuisz, a household pal of Holmes’ whom Gardner had met when she labored in healthcare at ALZA, reached out to ask for her opinion of Holmes. She was frank with him.
“I do not belief her,” she recalled telling Fuisz. “I do not know what she’s as much as.”
Theranos and Fuisz finally went to courtroom over a patent dispute, a tough expertise for Fuisz and his household. Gardner and Fuisz stayed in contact, finally connecting with Rochelle Gibbons, the widow of Ian Gibbons, the chief scientist at Theranos who killed himself in 2013.
The group would textual content about what they had been listening to about Theranos, particularly in mild of the corporate’s partnership with Walgreens, through which it arrange medical labs in sure pharmacies in Arizona to carry out its finger-stick assessments.
By 2014, Holmes was being featured on the covers of enterprise magazines and included on lists of high executives. Gardner wasn’t happy.
“I used to be simply barfing far and wide,” Gardner mentioned.
By no means miss out on healthcare information. Subscribe to Distributed, our weekly e-newsletter on pharma, biotech, and healthcare.
Stanford college students would ask to ask Holmes to talk as a feminine founder, however Gardner would not enable it.
“I help girls. I at all times have. I’ve gotten in hassle for it. I’ve pushed exhausting,” Gardner mentioned. “However I am not going to help a fraud — I do not care what your gender is.”
Then in October 2015, The Wall Avenue Journal’s John Carreyrou revealed his first article elevating questions on how the corporate’s know-how labored.
The day the article broke, Gardner, who was quoted in it, was at a Harvard Medical College board of fellows assembly. Holmes had been appointed to the board that summer season, so she was there as effectively.
Holmes and Gardner sat on reverse sides of the room, Gardner recalled. She mentioned she did not communicate to Holmes that day and saved her distance.
Holmes sat by means of the day of conferences, took a break to go on CNBC’s “Mad Cash” to dispute Carreyrou’s reporting, after which got here again for dinner. Holmes is not on the board.
Final June, Holmes stepped down as CEO of Theranos, remaining with the corporate as a founder and the chair of the board. She was charged with wire fraud by the Division of Justice; she has pleaded not responsible.
By September, Theranos had formally shut down, and its traders misplaced the lots of of hundreds of thousands they’d wager on the corporate.
Theranos is the main target of “The Inventor: Out for Blood in Silicon Valley,” a documentary debuting Monday at 9 p.m. ET on HBO.
For Gardner, the story nonetheless is not over.
“I simply need her convicted,” Gardner mentioned of Holmes. “All I would like is to see her in an orange jumpsuit with a black turtleneck accent.”
Her rationale for her dislike is straightforward.
“You place folks at risk,” Gardner mentioned. “I do not forgive that.”